A 5 L jerrycan can pass a drop test on the day it is made and still split at the base after a few weeks of contact with a solvent. Buyers usually blame the resin family, but the real question is narrower: how much density the container needs for stiffness, and how much stress-crack resistance that density costs. HDPE, LDPE and LLDPE sit on one trade-off curve, and the grade usually matters more than the family name.
The short answer: density buys stiffness, and you pay for it in ESCR
Start a 5 L jerrycan in HDPE, typically 0.94–0.96 g/cm³, because the container has to stack, hold its shape and resist bulging. Move toward LDPE or LLDPE when drop impact and stress cracking matter more than rigidity. Then check the specific grade's ESCR data, because two HDPE grades can behave very differently.
Density is shorthand for how tightly the polymer chains pack. As density rises, the material gets stiffer, resists creep under a stack load better, and gives a container that feels more rigid in the hand. The cost is in the tie between crystals: high-density grades have less of it, so a molded part under constant strain in a chemical environment cracks sooner. LDPE and LLDPE have lower density and more chain branching, which gives a softer part with better drop impact and environmental stress-crack resistance, but more wall thickness is needed to reach the same stiffness.
Stress cracking is a time-under-load failure, not an instant one. A container that holds a surfactant, oil or cleaning agent can crack at a corner or around a molded-in insert after weeks in storage, even when the wall thickness is correct. The test that matters is a constant-load or constant-strain ESCR test on the actual grade, in the actual medium, at the actual temperature. A resin-family label is not a substitute for that result.
- Stiffness and top load: higher density resists stacking and bulging with less wall thickness.
- ESCR: lower density and more branching usually improve resistance to chemical stress cracking.
- Impact: softer LDPE and LLDPE grades absorb drops better; very stiff HDPE can be brittle in the cold.
- Shrinkage: density and grade affect shrinkage, so dimensions and cooling are checked with the actual resin.
HDPE vs LDPE vs LLDPE at a glance
The table is a starting frame, not a grade selection. Every value shifts with comonomer, molecular weight and additives, so confirm it on the resin datasheet and in a trial.
| Resin family | Typical density | Stiffness | ESCR (relative) | Drop impact | Typical containers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HDPE | 0.94–0.96 g/cm³ | High | Moderate, falls as density rises | Moderate | Jerrycans, detergent and chemical bottles, 20–30 L drums |
| LDPE | 0.91–0.925 g/cm³ | Low to moderate | Good | Good | Squeeze bottles, flexible tubes, soft lids |
| LLDPE | 0.915–0.925 g/cm³ | Moderate | Very good | Very good | Impact-resistant bottles, caps, containers that take drops |
Swipe the table to see all columns →
What the choice changes on the machine
The resin family changes the parison, not just the bottle. LDPE and LLDPE are softer in the melt and sag more, so die-gap profile, parison programming and cycle timing are set for the grade. HDPE holds its shape and tolerates faster take-off, but a high-density grade with poor ESCR still cracks if the mold corners are sharp. On a single-station ES-5LS (5 L, 100 kN clamp, 320 × 380 mm platen, 65–80 kg/h) the same mold runs HDPE or LLDPE, but screw, temperature profile and cooling must match the grade. For larger containers the ES-30L (30 L, 215 kN clamp, 580 × 740 mm platen, 100–120 kg/h) adds clamp force and platen area for a heavier part.
The grade and the ESCR test matter more than the family
Two grades sold as HDPE can behave differently in service. A copolymer grade with a broader molecular-weight distribution may give better ESCR at the same density than a homopolymer grade, and a small additive change can move the result again. The useful comparison is not HDPE versus LDPE in the abstract, but this grade, in this medium, at this temperature, in this wall thickness. Ask for the resin datasheet, the ESCR test method and the failure mode, then run trial containers through the same filling and storage conditions. The same rule applies when you change resin on a running job: re-qualify the bottle rather than assume the family label carries over.
For the container side, readstress cracking in HDPE containersand25 L lubricant oil bottle production. Machine options are onsingle-station 0–16 Landdouble-station 0–16 L; for barrier containers seemulti-layer EVOH.
What to send for a quotation
A quotation is only useful if it matches the container you actually fill. Send these points and the machine, screw and mold cooling can be checked against a real part.
- Container drawing or sample: volume, wall thickness, neck and handle, filled weight.
- Medium and fill temperature: water, oil, surfactant, solvent or food, with concentration and contact time.
- Current resin grade and datasheet: density, melt index and any ESCR data.
- Output target: good parts per hour and shift pattern, so cavities and stations can be sized.
- Mold plan: existing tool or new mold, cavity count and drawing status.
- Destination and power supply: voltage, frequency, and site compressed-air and cooling capacity.
- Test standard the container must pass, and the drop or stack test you already use.
Source: E-SHION product data. Specifications are subject to change without notice; customization is available.
This guide is written for production and procurement decisions. It uses published figures where available and avoids unverified performance claims.